Editor of journal Physical Review A (American Physical Society, New York), Dr Gordon W. F. Drake does eighth Class Math wrong in report dated 19 June 2009 of paper DQ10345A, generalizing Einstein''s mass energy equation. The 15 page letter written to Editor-in-Chief, Dr Gene D. Sprouse and Dr Drake is quoted in original in the book after Chapter 5 in appendix. Even a student of eighth class knows that in subtraction of equations, LHS is subtracted from LHS and RHS subtracted from RHS of the other equation. Dr Drake had not subtracted LHS from LHS and jumped to conclusions. It is an elementary mistake. Then in report dated 9 October 2009, Dr Drake did another mistake by applying Law of Conservation of Energy incorrectly which is taught in eleventh class, to cover up his previous mistake. Why Galileo like punishment is being given to Ajay Sharma in modern era?